The Best Stuffed Dog Toys

Exercise is essential to a healthy and happy pup, and one of the best ways to get them the daily stimulation they need is with a toy. Stuffed toys are a popular choice among pet owners, as they feature cute designs, are soft to chew on, and can be thrown for a game of fetch without causing too much damage to surroundings. If you’re looking more pet toys that are great for your dog to chew on, read our list of the best dog chew toys.

Finding the best stuffed dog toy for your pet means reading reviews, studying product features, and diving into the ins and outs of available sizes and configurations. With the right stuffed dog toy, you and your pet will look forward to play time together.

We reviewed dozens of stuffed dog toys to identify the best of the best, based on Amazon reviews, how well they performed in durability tests, cost, and other considerations. We narrowed our search down to 5 of the top-rated stuffed dog toys pet owners can purchase to ensure a happy and healthy dog.

Top Pick
Outward Hound Hide-A-Squirrel and Puzzle

Engage your dog’s prey drive with this fun puzzle toy

$29.99 USD

We’ve identified the Outward Hound Hide-A-Squirrel and Puzzle Plush Squeaking Toys as the best stuffed dog toy out there. With it’s cute little squeaky squirrel friends in a hideout, this stuffed dog toy is one that will keep your pooch in tip top shape while satisfying their natural prey instincts and need for mental stimulation.

The 5 Top-Rated Stuffed Dog Toys for 2018

Editor's PicksBrandRating
Best OverallOutward Hound Hide-A-Squirrel and Puzzle Plush Squeaking Toys4.4
Runner UpMultipet Duckworth Duck4.1
Best Budget BuyMultipet Gumby Dog Toy4.1
Best Plush Squeak Dog ToyKONG Floppy Knots Dog Toy3.8
Best Plush Crinkle Dog ToyPet Qwerks Plush Krinkle and Squeak Newspaper4.0

*Ratings are from Amazon at the time of publication and can change

Our Top Pick: Outward Hound Hide-A-Squirrel and Puzzle Plush Squeaking Toys

The Outward Hound Hide-A-Squirrel and Puzzle Plush Squeaking Toys is our top pick for the best stuffed dog toy. It comes complete with 3-6 squirrel plushies with squeakers inside, depending on which size you choose. It comes in size options from small to ginormous — making it ideal for all breeds of dogs. The squirrels can be used for a sniff and hunt game, or tossed about for a game of fetch, providing plenty of playtime options for your pup.

Those who purchased and reviewed this stuffed dog toy appreciated that their dogs found the toy so much fun, and that they could order replacement squirrels when theirs were “killed.”  Something owners of this toy found that it did not stand up well to chewing, so shouldn’t be used unsupervised. However, when used as an interactive toy with your pooch and put away after use, many said it lasted several months or longer.

At a cost of around $17, it’s surprisingly affordable considering the amount of play options you get from it, which we think more than justifies that price. It has a rating of 4.4 on Amazon with more than 10,000 people reviewing it, which we think goes a long way in convincing pet owners to make the investment.

Outward Hound Hide-A-Squirrel and Puzzle Plush Squeaking Toys Key Features:

  • Available with other animals
  • Engaging puzzle plush play
  • Provides both mental enrichment and physical exercise

Our Runner-Up Pick: Multipet Duckworth Duck

Runner Up
Multipet Duckworth Duck

A classic stuffed toy that makes a wonderful companion

$8.99 USD

The Multipet Duckworth Duck earned the second place spot on our list of the best stuffed dog toys, and is a pretty straightforward toy. It features a fun and playful duck shape that is plenty of fun for dogs to chew, toss, and play fetch with. It’s also available in a 2-pack, if you want to always have one on standby. It features a large design that means it won’t be a choke hazard, and is suitable for play by pooches of all sizes — although tiny pups might find it difficult to drag around.

Those who purchased and reviewed this stuffed dog toy appreciated that their pets found this duck to be a comforting companion, with several carrying it around with them and snuggling it throughout the day. Plenty of big dog owners were surprised how quickly their pooches took to this toy.

With price of around $8, it’s a very affordable toy option for most pet owners, and the interactive play and solo fun it provides more than justifies that price. It has a rating of 4.1 on Amazon with more than 3,500 people reviewing it, which we think goes a long way in convincing pet owners to make the investment.

Multipet Duckworth Duck Key Features:

  • Squeaker included
  • Approximately 15-inch long
  • Not for heavy chewers

Best Budget Pick: Multipet Gumby Dog Toy

Best for Budget
Multipet Gumby Dog Toy

A budget-friendly option with fun design pet parents love

$6.38 USD

The Multipet Gumby Dog Toy takes the classic character of Gumby and blends it into a stuffed dog toy that’s great for a game of fetch with your pooch. This is an officially licensed product, and includes a squeaker for added playtime fun.

Those who purchased and reviewed this stuffed dog toy appreciated that it could be washed to help prolong use and keep it clean, which meant owners were more likely to engage in play. Some pet owners did mention that this toy did not stand up to very much chewing by their pet, and so they wouldn’t recommend it for dogs that are heavy chewers. If your pup just likes to carry around and snuggle with their stuffies, however, it’s ideal for that.

At a cost of $4, this stuffed dog toy is a solid choice for those looking for a stuffed dog toy option on a budget. It has a rating of 4.1 on Amazon with more than 550 people reviewing it, which we think goes a long way in convincing pet owners that this budget-friendly pick is just as good at entertaining their pup as its more expensive counterparts.

Multipet Gumby Dog Toy Key Features:

  • Available in single or multipack
  • Approximately 8.5-inch long
  • Suitable for dogs of all sizes

Best Plush Squeak Dog Toy: KONG Floppy Knots Dog Toy

Best Plush Squeak Dog Toy
KONG Floppy Knots Dog Toy

Durable design that’s suitable for all breeds and is stuffing-free

$15.99 USD

The KONG Floppy Knots Dog Toy is a favorite among dogs and their owners alike. It boasts the same durability that KONG toys are known for, but in a softer package. This toy is available in a choice of sizes for dogs of all breeds, as well as different animals to help entice your pet to play. The knotted design is perfect for chewing and thrashing, and helps increase the longevity of the toy.

Those who purchased and reviewed this stuffed dog toy appreciated that this toy was so well-made, with several owners of heavy chewers saying this toy was still going strong after weeks of daily wear and tear. The thick material stood up well to puppies who liked to chew, and many found the rope “skeleton” felt surprisingly soft and plush through the body material, even without any stuffing.

At a cost of around $14, it’s about middle of the road as far as dog toys cost, but the quality craftsmanship associated with the brand more than justifies that price. It has a rating of 3.8 on Amazon with more than 500 people reviewing it, which we think goes a long way in convincing pet owners to make the investment.

KONG Floppy Knots Dog Toy Key Features:

  • No stuffing for less mess
  • Multiple squeakers for added fun
  • Varied textures to engage dogs

Best Plush Crinkle Dog Toy: Pet Qwerks Plush Krinkle and Squeak Newspaper

Best Plush Crinkle Dog Toy
Pet Qwerks Plush Krinkle and Squeak Newspaper

Squeakers and crinkly paper make this a favorite of playful pooches

$4.99 USD

The Pet Qwerks Plush Krinkle and Squeak Newspaper features a realistic newspaper design that’s sure to bring a smile to your face as you enjoy playtime with your pooch. It is made from durable heavy canvas material, with crinkly material and squeakers inside. There’s also a small amount of stuffing to make the toy more comfortable, but not so much that you’ll be picking it up forever if your dog destroys the toy.

Those who purchased and reviewed this stuffed dog toy appreciated the crinkle sound of this toy, which dogs seemed to enjoy. Some owners felt this toy didn’t stand up to heavy chewing, but others got years of use out of it. A game of tug is no match for this newspaper, which stands up well to pulling.

With a price tag of around $5, it’s a very affordable option for those looking to get a stuffed toy for their dog, and the cute design combined with the fun crinkly paper more than justifies that price. It has a rating of 4.0 on Amazon with more than 150 people reviewing it, which we think goes a long way in convincing pet owners that this toy is worth the investment.

Pet Qwerks Plush Krinkle and Squeak Newspaper Key Features:

  • Available in a choice of sizes
  • Includes three squeakers
  • Fun for chewing and fetching

Who Should Buy a Stuffed Dog Toy

A stuffed dog toy is an ideal choice for almost any dog. Part of keeping a dog healthy and happy is providing them with enough exercise, entertainment, and mental stimulation throughout the day. Toys, including stuffed dog toys, can help your pet meet their daily needs.

A stuffed dog toy can also be a calming object for your pup. As such, dogs who exhibit especially anxious or destructive behavior can really benefit from having a stuffed toy of their own.

Top Pick
Outward Hound Hide-A-Squirrel and Puzzle

Engage your dog’s prey drive with this fun puzzle toy

$29.99 USD

Important Features to Consider

Not all stuffed dog toy are created equal. A stuffed dog toy should be entertaining for your pup, but also not something they’ll choke on. Here’s what to consider when evaluating the options in search of the best stuffed dog toy for your pooch:

  • Size. One of the most important considerations when choosing the best stuffed dog toy for your pooch is size. You want a toy that is large enough that your pet won’t choke on it or get it stuck in its mouth, but not so large that they can’t enjoy playing with it or have trouble carrying it.
  • Squeaker. Most dogs enjoy stuffed toys with squeakers inside them, but you need to make sure that your pup can’t access the squeaker as it poses a choke hazard. It is important to regularly inspect your pet’s toys to see where the squeaker is, and to supervise them with toys that contain squeakers.
  • Stuffing. Stuffing makes dog toys soft and fun to chew — it’s also enjoyable for dogs to pull out of their toys. Keep an eye if your pup is eating the stuffing though, as you may need to remove the toy if that’s the case.
  • Materials. Stuffed dog toys come in various materials, with some being more durable than others. If your pup is a heavy chewer, look for toys made from more durable materials such as fire hose rubber.
  • Price point. Finally, consider how much you are willing to spend on a stuffed dog toy. Stuffed dog toys vary in price from $5-$50 or more. You can frequently find sales that can make buying stuffed dog toys more affordable, but keep in mind that any toy will eventually wear out and need replaced.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you know if a stuffed dog toy is safe?

You know if a stuffed dog toy is safe if it is the right size for your pup, is free of any obvious dangers such as strings and ribbons, and that they don’t contain any dangerous fillings. Dangerous fillings include nutshells and polystyrene beads, although no filling is truly “safe” for dogs to ingest.

What stuffed dog toy materials are most durable?

The most durable dog toys are made from solid hard rubber, but this generally cannot be stuffed. Some toys have hard rubber balls or tugs on the end of the stuffed part. If this is not available, fire hose is another durable dog toy material. Fabric dog toys are made more durable with techniques such as double stitches and layering of fabrics, but are certainly not indestructible.

Why does my dog rip the stuffing out of stuffed dog toys?

Dogs rip the stuffing out of stuffed dog toys as a nod to their instinctual behavior and hunting past. Not long ago, dogs needed to hunt and kill their food. Part of this involved removing the innards of whatever prey they’d killed, and removing the stuffing out of stuffed dog toys gives this same sort of experience, which is probably why they enjoy it so much. There isn’t much you can do to stop this behavior, so it’s simply best just to provide your pooch with safe toys they enjoy.

Will eating stuffing make my dog sick?

There are some dog toy stuffings that are marketed as “safe” for dogs to ingest, however, that isn’t entirely true. The most dangerous fillings for dogs to consume include nutshells and polystyrene beads, although even “safe” stuffings can cause problems — especially if they’re ingested in large amounts. Eating stuffing can make a dog very sick, as it can cause an intestinal blockage — a potentially life-threatening condition. Some materials are toxic for pups and can cause vomiting, diarrhea, and lethargy.

Other Stuffed Dog Toys We Reviewed

Top Pick
Outward Hound Hide-A-Squirrel and Puzzle

Engage your dog’s prey drive with this fun puzzle toy

$29.99 USD

We looked at 20 other stuffed dog toys. Even though they didn’t make our 5 best stuffed dog toys list, they’re the best of the rest and each is still a great option for your pet. The information you’ll need to compare each one is included with the listing.

Plush Squeak Dog Toys

Multipet Plush Dog Toy Lambchop

Multipet Plush Dog Toy Lambchop

This Lambchop plush toy is a classic, and favorite among dogs of all ages and sizes. It is extremely soft and squeaks when played with.

Key Features:

  • 10-inch tall
  • Includes five squeakers
  • Available in single or multipacks

Cost: $4

ZippyPaws Woodland Friends Burrow

ZippyPaws Woodland Friends Burrow

Let your dog engage their natural hunting instinct with this fun puzzle toy. The cute squirrels are sure to provide hours of entertainment for your pooch.

Key Features:

  • Choice of sizes
  • Squeakers inside squirrels
  • Other animals available

Cost: $13

Multipet Swingin Slevin XXL Oversized 30-Inch Spotted Cow Plush Dog Toy

Multipet Swingin Slevin XXL Oversized 30-Inch Spotted Cow Plush Dog Toy

This extra-large dog toy is perfect for the biggest canines who still want to enjoy their own stuffy friend.

Key Features:

  • Includes five squeakers
  • Ideal for play and fetch
  • 30-inch long

Cost: $10

NANDOG My BFF Sheep Plush Dog Squeaky Toy

NANDOG My BFF Sheep Plush Dog Squeaky Toy

This cute little sheep plush not only features a squeaker for plenty of enjoyment, its ears are made from crinkle material for even more fun!

Key Features:

  • Choice of colors
  • 15-inch long
  • For small- to medium-sized dogs

Cost: $12

Haute Diggity Dog Muttini Bar Collection Squeaky Plush Dog Toy

Haute Diggity Dog Muttini Bar Collection Squeaky Plush Dog Toy

Available in a choice of different styles, this squeaky beer toy boasts a soft texture and punny label.

Key Features:

  • 8-inch long
  • Choice of sizes
  • Perfect for themed photos

Cost: $14

Hartz Nature’s Collection Quackers Plush Duck Dog Toy

Hartz Nature's Collection Quackers Plush Duck Dog Toy

This plush stuffed toy for dogs features a lifelike and lovable duck shell that provides your pooch with an interactive squeaker ideal for dynamic play.

Key Features:

  • Choice of sizes
  • Choice of animals
  • Suitable for heavy chewers

Cost: $7

HuggleHounds Plush Corduroy Durable Knotties Dog Toy

HuggleHounds Plush Corduroy Durable Knotties Dog Toy

Made of soft and durable corduroy plush, these stuffed dog toys have been designed to withstand heavy chewing, and each arm and foot features a great knot perfect for a game of tug.

Key Features:

  • Choice of sizes
  • Choice of animals
  • Machine washable

Cost: $15

KONG Funzler Plush Dog Toy

KONG Funzler Plush Dog Toy

This stuffed toy features a fun ball shape and includes six squeakers in order to grab your dog’s attention. The handles make playing a game of tug a cinch.

Key Features:

  • Choice of colors
  • Interactive or solo play
  • Includes six squeakers

Cost: $8

Dog Diggin Designs Runway Pup Collection

Dog Diggin Designs Runway Pup Collection

For the pampered pooch, this stuffed dog toy is a must-have! With cute designs featuring funny puns of popular designer brands, you’ll both have a smile with this interactive toy.

Key Features:

  • Choice of sizes
  • Includes a squeaker
  • Choice of designers

Cost: $13

Plush Crinkle Dog Toys

ZippyPaws – Jigglerz Junior Tough No Stuffing Squeaky Plush Dog Toy with Crinkle Head and Tail

ZippyPaws - Jigglerz Junior Tough No Stuffing Squeaky Plush Dog Toy with Crinkle Head and Tail

The double layer fabric and cross-stitched design provide increased durability that can withstand any rough play time for loads of fun.

Key Features:

  • Choice of animals
  • Stuffing-free
  • Unique jiggler noisemaker

Cost: $6.97

EETOYS Crinkle Squeaky Dog Chew Toy

EETOYS Crinkle Squeaky Dog Chew Toy

Ideal for small- and medium-sized dogs, this toy features crinkle paper in the body, a squeaker in the head, and plenty of knots for a game of tug.

Key Features:

  • 11-inch long
  • Machine washable
  • Lightweight design

Cost: $10

Stuffing-Free Plush Dog Toys

Outward Hound Fire Biterz Plush Dog Toy

Outward Hound Fire Biterz Plush Dog Toy

This plush dog toy comes stuffing-free, making it ideal for dogs who tend to chew and ingest the filling from regular toys. It is crafted from real fire hose for increased durability and longevity.

Key Features:

  • Choice of sizes
  • Choice of animals
  • Suitable for indoor or outdoor play

Cost: $8

Ethical Pet Plush Skinneeez 24-Inch Dog Toy

Ethical Pet Plush Skinneeez 24-Inch Dog Toy

This dog toy comes without any potentially harmful stuffing, but still features a squeaker to help engage and entertain your pooch.

Key Features:

  • 24-inch long
  • Choice of animals
  • Helps satisfy natural hunting instinct

Cost: $5

ZippyPaws Deluxe Water Bottle Crusherz

ZippyPaws Deluxe Water Bottle Crusherz

For dogs who love to chew and enjoy crinkle noises, this toy is a great bet. Place a water bottle inside for hours of safe chewing and play.

Key Features:

  • Choice of animals
  • Includes one water bottle
  • Reinforced 2-layer fabric for durability

Cost: $7

Ethical Pet Plush Skinneeez Bungee Fox Stuffingless Dog Toy

Ethical Pet Plush Skinneeez Bungee Fox Stuffingless Dog Toy

Ideal for a rousing game of fetch with your pooch, this toy uses a bungee mechanism to fling itself through the air, and makes a wonderful tug toy.

Key Features:

  • Stretches to 36-inches
  • Squeaker inside
  • Choice of animals

Cost: $7

Squeaker-Free Plush Dog Toys

Hartz Stunt Pilots Plush Slingshot Chicken Dog Toy

Hartz Stunt Pilots Plush Slingshot Chicken Dog Toy

For pups who can’t be trusted with squeaker-filled toys, this chicken is a great choice, and uses a launching mechanism for a fun game of fetch.

Key Features:

  • Suitable for indoor or outdoor play
  • Motion-activated clucking
  • Ideal for gifting

Cost: $9

HDP MultiPet Deedle Dudes Mouse

HDP MultiPet Deedle Dudes Mouse

Ideal for dogs with visual impairment, this toy features a musical mechanism that plays a tune when squeezed. Use it to grab your pup’s attention for playtime, or to help orient them.

Key Features:

  • Available in single or multipack
  • Plush filled
  • 8-inch long

Cost: $5

Multipet Deedle Dude 8-Inch Singing Monkey Plush Dog Toy

Multipet Deedle Dude 8-Inch Singing Monkey Plush Dog Toy

This little stuffy plays a sweet song your dog is sure to find soothing when it is squeezed. Fun for fetching and playing, it’s also comforting to nervous pooches.

Key Features:

  • 8-inch long
  • Squeaky toy alternative
  • Joyful tune

Cost: $5

PAWABOO Stuffed Animal Toy Plush

PAWABOO Stuffed Animal Toy Plush

This cute little stuffed dog toy has been made with superior soft faux-fur and high-quality fabrics to provide dogs with hours of fun play. It is made with non-toxic and odorless materials.

Key Features:

  • Choice of animals
  • 6-inch long
  • Machine washable

Cost: $15

Hyper Pet Doggie Pal Plush Interactive Dog Toys

Hyper Pet Doggie Pal Plush Interactive Dog Toys

Perfect for a game of tug or simply just for chewing, this dog toy features a realistic tail look that helps satisfy the natural prey instinct of your canine.

Key Features:

  • Choice of animals
  • Toy jumps and wiggles
  • Automatic shutoff conserves battery power

Cost: $11

Products You May Be Interested In: