Pet Food & Treats

As pet parents, you probably spend a lot of time thinking about the food your dog eats: What are the best organic dog foods? Which brands offer the best nutrition? What flavors does your pup like the best? Which foods offer the best cost-value balance? From natural dog foods to organic pet food delivery services; then there are grain-free options, wholesome and holistic offerings, and high-protein dog foods – both as dried kibble and canned wet food – there are plenty of options for you to evaluate. Finding the right natural or organic dog food for your pet means reading reviews, studying ingredients lists, and diving into the ins and outs of natural vs. grain-free vs. organic dog foods.

If you are interested in seeing some other food or treat options for your pets, make sure to check out our pet food and treats articles.

We reviewed dozens of organic and natural dog food brands to find the best of the best, based on Amazon reviews, quality of ingredients, cost, and other considerations. We narrowed our search down to 5 of the top-rated natural and organic dog foods pet parents can purchase to ensure a healthy diet for their dog.

Best Organic Dog Food Overall
Organix Organic Canned Adult Dog Food
USDA-certified organic with no GMOs, this is the ideal choice for your dog if only the best of the best organic food will do.

We’ve identified Organix Organic Canned Adult Dog Food as the best bet. Boasting the highest quality ingredients and no added hormones or antibiotics, this organic dog food will provide your dog  with the essential nutrients they need for their health.

The 5 Top-Rated Organic Dog Foods

Editor's PicksBrandRating
Best Organic Dog Food OverallOrganix Organic Canned Adult Dog Food
4.2
Best Organic Chicken Dog FoodLily's Kitchen Organic Chicken and Spelt Supper for Dogs4.1
Best Budget Organic Dog FoodNewman's Own Adult Dog Food Formula4.6
Best Organic Dog Food for Small BreedsOrganix Small Breed Recipe Dry Dog Food4.3
Best Organic Vegetable Dog FoodNummy Tum Tum Pure Pumpkin For Pets4.6

*Ratings are from Amazon at the time of publication and can change

Best Organic Dog Food Overall: Organix Organic Canned Adult Dog Food

Organix Organic Canned Adult Dog Food is our pick of all of the organic dog foods on the market for a multitude of reason. The USDA certified organic food also guarantees no GMOs, so if you’re strict on the certifications your dog food has – this is the one for you. As the manufacturer says, “The potential benefits of an organic diet for your dog or cat include a reduction of allergies and itchy skin, reduced digestion problems, and better health overall.”

You can also be sure that this food has none of the extras that may be bad for your pooch. No added hormones or antibiotics, no artificial preservatives or chemical pesticides; only ingredients you wouldn’t mind eating yourself. It comes in a variety of different flavors and each one lists the #1 ingredient as meat (either chicken or turkey). The remaining ingredients are vegetables and/or brown rice and other super foods that will make sure your dog is getting optimum nutrition.

One thing you may consider worthy of note is the layer of fat that often hardens on the top of the can. Not only is this something you shouldn’t worry about, it’s a sign of “real food” ingredients. When you pull your leftover pot roast from the refrigerator you see the same layer and for the same reason: Fat hardens when it cools. You can stir it enthusiastically or warm it a bit before serving and your dog will lap it right up.

Organix Organic Canned Adult Dog Food Key Features:

  • USDA certified organic ingredients, formulated with essential vitamins and minerals
  • No chemicals, chemical pesticides, hormones or antibiotics
  • Variety of flavors
  • Product of the USA

Best Organic Chicken Dog Food: Lily’s Kitchen Organic Chicken and Spelt Supper for Dogs

Best Organic Chicken Dog Food
Lily's Kitchen Organic Chicken and Spelt Supper for Dogs
A well-balanced, healthy diet for your dog, Lily’s Kitchen Organic Chicken and Spelt Supper for Dogs is packed with 50% certified organic meat.

Lily’s Kitchen Organic Chicken and Spelt Supper for Dogs doesn’t mess around when it comes to high-quality, organic ingredients. Each can contains a whooping 50% certified organic meat. Specifically, each formula is made up of 30% organic chicken, 30% organic pork, and 10% organic turkey. What’s more, the formula also boasts organic fruits, vegetables, and botanical herbs.

In terms of dog food, this is considered to be a very high percentage of organic ingredients used. Keep in mind that many brands try to get away with labeling their food “organic” even though the formula only contains a minuscule amount of organic ingredients.

In each order, you’ll receive a total of 11 cans. In addition to being organic, the recipe is formulated to be free of derivatives, preservatives and fillers. You’ll also be interested to learn that the recipe is also wheat-free, making it a tempting choice if your dog has a sensitivity or allergy to wheat.

Lily’s Kitchen Organic Chicken and Spelt Supper for Dogs Key Features:

  • 30% organic chicken, 30% organic pork, and 10% organic turkey
  • No derivatives, preservatives, or fillers
  • Wheat-free
  • 11 cans

Best Budget Organic Dog Food: Newman’s Own Adult Dog Food Formula

Best Budget Organic Dog Food
Newman's Own Adult Dog Food Formula
An excellent choice for the budget-minded pet parent who wants the best for their dog at only $0.14 per ounce.

Chances are that you’ve heard of Newman’s Own, but did you know that it’s one of the best organic dog food brands today? Newman’s Own Adult Dog Food Formula is a budget-friendly, big-name natural dog food that focuses on your pup’s nutritional needs without the extra fuss or extra cash. At less than $30 for a 12.5 pound bag, you won’t break the bank making sure your fury friend gets the quality they deserve. If that still sounds a lot, consider the fact that equates to $0.14 per ounce!

This budget-friendly kibble contains organic grains and veggies, as well as real chicken as the first ingredient, to achieve the optimal protein-fat balance that adult dogs need. You only need to take a look at the ingredients label to see for yourself how nutritious it is. After chicken, you’ll find organic barley, oats, and peas.

Your dog is bound to appreciate the thought put into making this corn and wheat free recipe. What’s more, you can buy it with the peace of mind that 100% of profits from sales go to charity. Needless to say, very few brands can boast such generosity!

Newman’s Own Adult Dog Food Formula Key Features:

  • $0.14 per ounce
  • Real chicken
  • Organic grains and veggies
  • 100% of profits from sales go to charity

Best Organic Dog Food for Small Breeds: Organix Small Breed Recipe Dry Dog Food

Best Organic Dog Food for Small Breeds
Organix Small Breed Recipe Dry Dog Food
Made with USDA-certified organic, free-range chicken, this offering from Organix provides protein-packed organic meal for your dog.

Let your dog indulge with Organix Small Breed Recipe Dry Dog Food by satisfying his appetite for real meat, with no grains, gluten or fillers. This organic dog food is made from USDA-certified organic, free-range chicken.

The meat is sourced in the USA and freeze dried raw, providing him as close to an ancestral meal as you can pick up in the dog food aisle. This may even be better, because you can ensure the meat he’s consuming comes from meat raised organically and produced naturally. The recipe is packed with a dog superfood blend of organic flaxseed, organic blueberries, and organic coconut oil.

Because the food is packed with nutrients and taste, you can even use each of these bits as individual treats, if you so choose. You can, of course, serve it as a standalone meal, or mix into your pup’s favorite kibble.

Organix Small Breed Recipe Dry Dog Food Key Features:

  • 6 Available Flavors
  • 100% free-range and organic. Made with probiotics and prebiotic fiber
  • No artificial preservatives, chemical pesticides, no fillers, no grains, no coloring, and added growth hormones or antibiotics
  • Made in an organically certified kitchen in the USA

Best Organic Vegetable Dog Food: Nummy Tum Tum Pure Pumpkin For Pets

Best Organic Vegetable Dog Food
Nummy Tum Tum Pure Pumpkin For Pets
Made with 100% pure and USDA Organic pumpkin sourced from local farms, just one spoonful a day will help to keep your dog healthy.

We recommend Nummy Tum Tum Pure Pumpkin For Pets with full confidence if you’re after an vegetable-based organic dog food for your pooch. In fact, this fiber-rich food only contains a total of one ingredient: 100% pure and USDA Organic pumpkin sourced from local farms.

It’s important to keep in mind that this food shouldn’t make up the bulk of your dog’s diet as it’s formulated for intermittent or supplemental feeding. The manufacturers recommend adding 1 tablespoon daily per 10 lbs. weight of dry food. You can use it as a daily food supplement, special treat, or digestive aid. Since it’s low-calorie, very flavorful, and high in fiber, it also makes the perfect addition to a weight-management dog diet.

In each order, a total of 12 x 15 oz. cans, all of which boast a BPA-free liner. In terms of feedback, Nummy Tum Tum Pure Pumpkin For Pets has an impressive rating of 4.6 on Amazon.

Nummy Tum Tum Pure Pumpkin For Pets Key Features:

  • 100% pure and USDA Organic
  • Sourced from local farms
  • 12 x 15 oz. cans
  • Made in the USA

Who Should Buy Organic Dog Food?

If you buy organic food for yourself then you very likely already know the answer to why a person should feed their dog organic. In 2013, Ria Chhabra did a middle school Science Fair project where she compared the effects of fruit flies eating an all organic diet to fruit flies eating non-organic foods of the same type. The NY Times wrote an article on her findings in 2013 claiming, “By nearly every measure, including fertility, stress resistance and longevity, flies that fed on organic bananas and potatoes fared better than those who dined on conventionally raised produce.”

You should note, however, that the label of “Organic” does not necessarily make your dog’s food healthier. There is organic candy, after all. You can have organic sugars and fruits and even organic grains that are disproportionate to the meat in your dog food. You should still look at the ingredients to make sure that what you’re feeding your dog is healthy. You can feed your dog a healthy diet without it being organic and you can feed your dog an organic food and it still be incredibly unhealthy.

Best Organic Dog Food Overall
Organix Organic Canned Adult Dog Food
USDA-certified organic with no GMOs, this is the ideal choice for your dog if only the best of the best organic food will do.

Important Features to Consider

Not all natural or organic dog foods are created equal. Here’s what to consider when evaluating the options in search of the best natural or organic diet for your pet:

  • Organic vs. natural. When dealing with dog food, ‘Natural’ and ‘Organic’ are often used in conjunction, but not always. The term ‘Natural’ generally means the meat was produced naturally, without any artificial ingredients; usually coloring, flavors, sweeteners or preservatives. But ‘Natural’ doesn’t apply to the way the meat was produced; so the cows or chickens could have been fed hormones or antibiotics. ‘Organic’ refers to the way the meat was produced and the end result; meaning they must be fed an all organic diet and have a higher standard of living conditions.
  • Grain-free vs. gluten-free. It’s important to note that gluten-free isn’t the same as grain-free, so if for some reason you suspect your dog has an allergy to grains, you’ll need to look a bit deeper than just a gluten-free dog food. There are types of grain that do not contain gluten and therefore you can get a gluten-free dog food that still contains grains. If you’re trying to avoid any “filler” ingredients and you think grain may be that for your dog, look out for the common “gluten-free grains,” including quinoa, amaranth and buckwheat.
  • Select organic ingredients vs. all-organic. Once you’ve determined that the way the food was raised is important to you, you’ll need to look even closer at that label. If the label reads “USDA Organic” the contents are at least 95% organic as is recognized by the USDA. The dog food that declares it is “Made with Organic Ingredients,” at least 70% of the ingredients meet the criteria for the USDA’s organic standards.
  • Non-generics. We don’t mean “name brand” when we write ‘generic;’ we mean in the ingredient list. You’ll want to stick to ingredients that give specifics. Avoid the “Meat protein,” “Animal By products” or “Animal Fat” and look for the animal and meat to be named specifically. The same will go for any ingredient. If it’s not named it could very well be a combination of otherwise unusable food. There’s a parallel between this and the meat that goes into a hot dog; except for dog food the standard is much lower than for human food.
  • Recognizable ingredients. Ideally, you should be able to recognize the bulk of your dog food’s ingredients. There are very likely minerals, vitamins and preservatives you won’t recognize but your pup may benefit by you familiarizing yourself with these so you can identify unwanted ingredients. Ingredient lists put what they contain the most of first so you want to look for a dog food that lists ingredients you recognize in the first handful of ingredients.
  • Recalls. Some ingredients have had mandatory recalls and others have had voluntary recalls. You may want to smarten up on past recalls to make sure you’re not getting a dog food that has ingredients other brands have voluntarily recalled. For example, recently a leading dog food manufacturer voluntarily recalled a number of its products after finding Pentobarbital within them. Pentobarbital is used in significantly greater doses to induce euthanasia on pets and therefore, probably not something you’d want to give your pooch. The FDA provides an updated list of pet food recalls for easy reference here, and the American Veterinary Medical Association maintains a list here. Another helpful resource for keeping an eye on dog food recalls is Dog Food Advisor.
  • Price point. At some point, you may find it’s simply less expensive to make your own dog food so you can better control the quality and freshness. But you will need to consider the time that goes into making these foods at home. Your time does equal money so don’t bite off more than you can chew or more than is financially worth it to you.
  • Regulations and certifications. The FDA is the primary source that regulates dog food and each state has a Department of Agriculture that has a secondary authority over pet food; both of these agencies regulate but do not always enforce. The USDA and the AAFCO have no regulatory authority but have voluntary inspections in place to gain food certification. If it’s certified, you’ll see it very clearly on the label. Note, though not all dog foods are certified, the certification process is often pricey and some companies just opt not to go through that. And very often it’s just the ingredients that are certified. So it will say, for example, “Made with USDA beef” but the dog food itself isn’t certified.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are grain-free dog foods better?

The primary justification for a grain-free diet for dogs is that their ancestors never ate grains of any kind and their bodies weren’t designed to process that kind of carbohydrate. The argument is made that because of this, grains aren’t good for dogs. But that’s only partly true. You won’t find many arguments claiming a grain-only diet is what’s best for your dog, but in the many generations of evolution between wolves and dogs, their bodies have changed and they are now completely capable of digesting grains. Grains aren’t necessary for them, though and just because their bodies are capable of it, doesn’t necessarily mean you should give it to them. There is no clear cut answer on this, barring a grain allergy, of course. You can check with your vet, but the chances are they’ll tell you the same thing we are: It’s up to you.

Can you give raw meat to a dog?

Feeding raw meat to a dog has come from the same thinking as the grain-free diet: That’s what their ancestors did. And while that is true, it is also true that it is not necessary. A raw dog food diet can be one your dogs responds very well to, but it must be treated more carefully than simply picking up a random bag of dog food. You can prepare the food yourself and if you choose to do that, you’ll have to be careful with the meat you choose and how you handle the raw meats to avoid bacterial contamination.

If you choose to purchase raw pet food, you’ll have to worry substantially less (but keep in mind you will still need to keep an eye on your dog’s response to the raw food diet). Dog Food Manufacturers need to adhere to FDA suggested regulations, but remember, no matter how strictly they adhere to those regulations, raw food comes with a certain amount of risk of bacterial infections.

What is the healthiest food to feed your dog?

If you’re looking to make your own dog food, you’ll want to incorporate some dog super foods of which you may have never heard. Green Tripe, for example, isn’t something you typically see in your grocery store, but you can usually stop by the butcher’s shop and ask for it. (In case you’re wondering, Tripe is the stomach of a grazing animal. I.E. cows, buffalo, sheep.) You should also try to incorporate milk thistle, raw eggs, coconut oil and organ meats.

If you’re looking to buy a healthy dog food, we have some recommendations on brands but if you’re looking independently, you’ll want to look through ingredient lists to find a specific animal protein at the top of the list, whole vegetables fruits and grains and a protein meal combined with any fresh or frozen protein. Fresh and frozen contain up to 75% water, so combining it with a protein meal (which is only 10% water) will get you the most bang for your buck.

What is dog food made out of?

Obviously the answer to this question depends on what brand and type of dog food you buy. USDA has recently classified “Animal grade” food as not “generally recognized as safe” (GRAS) for human consumption, so you should take a look at your dog’s food closely. “Animal grade” food is not inspected and can include some pretty repulsive ingredients.  If it is approved by the USDA, it is not “animal grade” and therefore much higher quality. It will have the exact wording of “USDA approved” or “USDA Certified” if it is GRAS. Some dog foods will include a misleading label of “made with ingredients from a USDA facility” or “USA Meat” and can use the meat rejected from the human food chain.

Before you buy a dog food, take a look at the ingredients list; there are a few things you can keep in mind to help you decipher the quality of your dog’s food. The less expensive brands are generally poorer quality and higher priced are higher quality. But there are other factors to keep in mind. For example, if your dog food doesn’t list meat as it’s first ingredient, that’s usually a bad sign. Unspecified meat is another indicator that the quality isn’t especially high; that is, “Animal” or “Meat” instead of “Chicken” or “Beef.” You’ll also want to look for artificial flavoring, colors, and some preservatives. (Natural preservatives don’t preserve foods as long as the artificial ones, so always check your ‘best by’ dates.) Added sweeteners are often used to mask the taste of a primarily grain food so the dog will still eat it, despite it’s lack of protein.

Wet dog food is higher in moisture and often necessary for dogs with sore mouths or missing teeth. The recipes for wet dog foods are typically higher in protein and fat than the recipes for dry dog foods, but because it’s already wet, more will need to be consumed for proper nutrition. You will still need to make sure there is a decent meat to grain ratio, though, because often the protein gels will form meat-like chunks that give the illusion of more meat than is actually present.


Avatar